Imagine you’re hosting a party with one goal in mind: Everyone who attends enjoys a drink. To make sure you meet this goal, you whip up a batch of egg creams with milk, carbonated water, and flavored syrup. There’s one for everyone who’s coming to your party—but it’s the only drink available. Will you meet your goal by offering just one option? What about lactose-intolerant guests or those who don’t like fizzy drinks? Will they enjoy the drink you provided?
While this analogy might sound silly, it illustrates a phenomenon that happens in classrooms all the time when educators use one-size-fits-all solutions to teach their students. Luckily, with frameworks like universal design for learning (UDL), teachers can branch out from that cookie-cutter instruction to meet the needs of all their students.
Universal design for learning is a research-based educational framework designed to improve and optimize teaching for diverse learners. It’s so important that it’s mentioned by name in the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), which lays out the way national and state governments can help students succeed in school.
UDL focuses on flexibility and goal-setting to ensure that all learners have the options and choices they need to work toward grade-level standards. Without this flexibility, many students don’t have pathways to help them access learning with their peers.
But UDL is more than just a curriculum framework. It’s also a belief that all students are capable of learning and reaching grade-level milestones. With intentional instruction methods, educators can help all students succeed.
CAST, a nonprofit education research and development organization, created guidelines to help educators implement UDL in their districts, schools, and classrooms. These guidelines fall into three categories: Engagement, representation, and action and expression.
The engagement UDL principle looks at the brain’s affective networks and why students learn. The idea is that there isn’t just one way for students to engage with content or activities that’s perfect for all learners. Instead, students need a variety of engagement opportunities during a lesson or unit to connect with the content. Some ways teachers can spark engagement include:
The representation UDL principle focuses on the brain’s recognition networks and what students learn. Each student perceives and understands information differently. This happens because of their preferred learning styles or differing abilities like blindness, deafness, or dyslexia. The more ways teachers can differentiate content and activities to share information in multiple ways, the more accessible it becomes to their students. Some ways teachers can promote representation using the UDL framework include:
The action and expression UDL principle focuses on the brain’s strategic networks and how students learn. Showing what you know is an important part of learning. Educators assess their students to discover what they’ve learned and where there are still gaps in their knowledge. But a final summative exam or a standardized test isn’t the only way to collect this information.
Students demonstrate their skills differently based on certain factors like movement impairments, language barriers, and things like executive function disorders or anxiety. When teachers provide varied ways for students to display their knowledge and skills, they get a better idea of what students really know, not just how well they can take a test. Some ways teachers can vary action and expression methods with UDL include:
According to the Pew Research Center, 15% of the PreK-12 U.S. public school population during the 2021-22 school year was considered students with disabilities. In that same period, over 10% of the K-12 population of U.S. schools was considered ELLs. That’s a quarter of the school population alone that needs at least some type of assistance in the classroom. Adding UDL frameworks to your curriculum can accommodate diverse learning needs by:
It’s not surprising that lessons and activities incorporating the UDL framework look different in different classrooms. It’s not a one-size-fits-all approach, after all! But just because no two UDL implementations are exactly alike doesn’t mean that there aren’t some common themes that they all share. Classrooms that use UDL likely have five things in common:
How do you get your classroom to look like those using UDL frameworks? Here are some tips to start rolling out implementation:
All learners need options and choices to stay engaged. But having tons of choices in the classroom doesn’t mean you’re using universal design. UDL’s real power happens when you recognize barriers preventing your students from learning and eliminating them with intentional lesson design.
The first thing you can do is identify the firm goals of your lesson. Ask, “What do all my learners need to know and do?” Then, ask, “What’s preventing them from getting there?”
You may turn to your standards to help set these goals. For example, one of your anchor standards for comprehending text may be, “Analyze how two or more texts address similar themes or topics to build knowledge or compare the approaches the authors take.” This is your firm goal. How are you going to make sure all students reach it?
Providing a printed copy of two texts in English isn’t enough. This could exclude students with visual impairments or students who don’t speak English fluently. You could eliminate these barriers by providing texts and multimedia resources on the same topic and allowing students to choose the ones most interesting to them. Newsela text sets and collections are great resources for this type of differentiation.
This standard also doesn’t mention how students have to show that they understand how the texts address similar themes. This means you can let them choose how they want to show what they’ve learned. They might choose to complete a writing prompt, make a Venn diagram, or produce a podcast episode.
In classrooms where students have varying reading levels and learning needs, leveling texts can be a game changer for teachers. Reading appropriately complex texts lets students access grade-level curriculum and make progress in reading. According to educator and thought leader Timothy Shanahan, choosing when to provide different levels of text depends on the learning goal.
If your goals are to help students grow literacy skills or build comprehension strategies, providing complex texts at or above grade level in teacher-guided reading instruction and small peer groups can help. If your goals are for students to build background knowledge on a topic or read independently with fluency and accuracy, reading less complex texts at a reading level that’s just right for them could be a helpful option.
UDL is a helpful framework, but knowing when to offer a variety of less complex options and when to provide more scaffolds for reading at grade level is critical for helping all students learn and reach their goals.
Student choice and autonomy are wonderful things in the classroom, especially when using UDL frameworks. But decision-making isn’t an inherent skill. We need to teach students how to make responsible decisions that support their learning goals. We also need to teach them how to self-assess and self-reflect to see if their choices are helping them reach their goals.
As your students work in groups or independently, move around the classroom and ask them about their choices. Questions like “What did you choose to read?” or “Why did you choose that activity?” help them make connections between their choices and the learning outcomes. It also lets you provide feedback that helps them make more effective choices in the future.
For example, if four students choose to do group work, but they’re not actually working on the assignment, that’s an opportunity to guide their decisions. You may use that opportunity to say something like, “It seems like this choice isn’t working for you today. Why don’t we check in and pick something different that will help you succeed because I know you’re capable of success.” This is what expert learning is all about!
UDL helps avoid one-size-fits-all solutions and ensures that all students have access to high-quality education. Newsela ELA, Newsela Social Studies, Newsela Science, and Formative all have resources and scaffolds to support UDL frameworks and give students the support they need to succeed. Some features most helpful for UDL implementation include:
Not a Newsela customer yet? Sign up for Newsela Lite and Formative for free and get access to the resources and scaffolds you need to help students engage with content, comprehend information, and show what they know.
Discover what differentiated instruction is and four different ways you can modify instruction to better suit the needs of all students in your classroom.
As many educators know, the needs of students differ, so it is important that content is accessible for learners who need extra support or lack the required background knowledge. When that doesn’t occur, there is an accessibility gap.
Creating an optimal challenge for all learners meant providing three ingredients: access, relevance, and stretch.
East Orange School District filled curriculum gaps and engaged K-12 students using Newsela Social Studies, providing vetted, accessible content.
Using Formative assessments improves high school math scores, especially for low-SES and Hispanic students, meeting ESSA Tier III standards.
We’ve identified 12 areas where your schools and districts may benefit when transitioning to standards-based grading.